Aoud Shiny by Pierre Montale for Montale 2008

Hello fellow Fumies,

Have you ever read a bunch of reviews and they have frightened you off something? All I keep reading is about how harsh,  strong, powerful and long lasting the Montale fragrances are. That they are kick you in the head and then jump on your carcass as you lay there dead by asphyxiation. Recently on SurrenderToChance they had a DailyChanceSpecial on the Montale manufacturers samples where you could get them for only 99c each. Of course I grabbed a bunch and they have been sitting there unloved and unsniffed since because I had to wait for there to be nothing involving people to do and nobody awake to skunk. Tonight’s the night!!

Photo Stolen Fragrantica

Fragrantica gives these featured accords:
Bulgarian rose, violet leaf, oud, nagarmotha root (Cyperus scariosus), sandalwood, patchouli.

My skin completely explodes with crushed violet leaf, slightly earthy nagarmotha root and a soft, clean, oudh for the first 15-20 minutes. It is fresh and lively, green and summery, and not what I was expecting AT ALL. Ha ha ha! I often read about the moment when you start to think you know something about fragrance and you get all, “Oh, I know what this will be like because I’m a frag DIVA!” It’s at that exact time something will come along and surprise the shit out of you. Well, here it is! While being lush and wet, like walking through the immaculate gardens of a tropical resort after rain, this is not a big fragrance. Yes you are perfumed and fragrant, you have better than good sillage and sit still for a while and people will notice that you smell incredible but Aoud Shiny is not a skunker.

Photo Stolen novinite

Oh MY! This is the part where the Bulgarian roses come in and smack everything else down. I have been wearing Aoud Shiny by Montale for nearly 40 minutes and slowly the roses have been taking over, right now they are all there is. A lavish, slightly spicy, full blown rose: those big fat global roses that open up as big as a salad plate. CooEEEEEEE! This splendiferous rose remains front and centre for a good, long while, maybe 1.5-2 hours and then a spicy, minty, medical/chewing gum experience takes over (almost like the opening of Geranium Pour Monsieur but less intense). It’s not an oudh-ish medicine but a dentist surgery, get  it?

Photo Stolen inspiredbythis

One of the things I really enjoy about this fragrance is the amount of time you get with each stage of the fragrances development, now at around the 3-4 hour mark the sandalwood is making a big buttered wood statement that doesn’t run completely over the lingering violet leaf and rose, it’s a triumvirate with the sandalwood walking slightly ahead. at this point I start to feel like we are really about to arrive in a Middle Eastern fragrance. Here is where the real depths of the fragrance begin to shine. While still retaining its light and freshness Aoud Shiny gives up its hidden depths to us and will continue to do so for hours more yet. By the time I lose the fragrance I’ve stopped checking the time, so some time after the 7 hour mark but before 10 hours. EXCELLENT!

I couldn’t find a dedicated review of Aoud Shiny by any of my favoured bloggers but on Basenotes and Fragrantica there was a mixture of love and hate reviews.
ParfumsRaffy has a selection of Aoud Shiny $100/50ml & $165/100ml
SurrenderToChance starts at $4/ml

There were quite a few complaints that Montale was doing another Rose/Oudh fragrance. I am new to the line so for me it had a fresh, lovely and unusual approach towards these 2 main accords, lighter than the heavy Indian and Middle Eastern oils that I’m familiar with and heavier than almost all of the Western fragrances. A fine, balanced perfume with a great, long story to tell. I can’t wait to try another Montale.

Have you tried any of the Montales? Do you have a favourite? Please tell me below in the comments,
We at APJ hope that you have enjoyed dropping in and we hope to see you back tomorrow. Till then, take care of yourselves,
Portia xx

Here is a gorgeous Belly Dancing Artist who gives the idea a great new modern spin. Do Enjoy!!


47 comments on “Aoud Shiny by Pierre Montale for Montale 2008

  1. Ari says:

    No, I’ve never tried a single Montale! Like you, I’d been scared off by various reviews of the line (and their OVERWHELMING number of perfumes). This one sounds truly delightful, Portia! Thank you for putting in a good word for Montale!

  2. Margeaux says:

    I love your reviews Portia – they always make me smile with delight!

    • You rock my world Margeaux! Where are you currently? Kath said Perth? Singapore? Madrid? I can’t remember? Where ever you are, have some fun for Mummy please,
      Portia xx

      • Margeaux says:

        I was in Perth, off to Melbourne tonight. Gold Coast and Brisbane in November. Its travel travel travel sweetie darling! Hope to see you soon, may drop into the Newtown for Trivia next Monday night 🙂 xx

  3. Maria says:

    Hey Portia! I loved your review, I hope you will review the rest you purchased as well! It seems I took advantage of the same offer and bought everything StC had available (about 29 of them) and I am trying them a couple every day at work to get views from the coworkers! They are trully LONGlasting and the smallest amount goes at least 8-10 hours on me! This one is one of my favorites so far !! So far I didn’t get a negative comment everyone seems to like them I guess it is the weather changing to autumn and everyone is looking to something more earthy !!

    • Hey Maria!
      Thank you. I only grabbed 10 of them and am now kicking myself. As the weeks progress I will get to them all hopefully. What are your other faves so I can earmark them please?
      Portia xx

      • Maria says:

        Haven’t tried all of them yet, but I liked Aromatic Lime Fougeres MArines, oriental flowers, powder flowers(this one is very light ) sandflowers and velvet flowers! I have about a dozen more to try !

      • Having looked through my cache I found only Oriental Flowers in common. Such an ENORMOUS range. It will take me a year to try them all.
        Portia xx

      • Maria says:

        Today I will be trying crystal flowers @ crystal aoud! Don’t worry it took me a couple of weeks to actually open the box ! The quantity was overwhelming!

  4. Christos says:

    At last some love for this line! It is a shame I haven’t reviewed any but Patchouli (Leaves). I think that part of the blame is in the line itself for keeping throwing new releases at us. Very few are bad. Most of them are above average in my opinion. Most of them also have this uncanny ability to develop for hours and many reviewers have simply scrubbed them of or are sniffing something else before they get to the heart of them. I love Black Aoud of course, it is amazing how a fresh rose can be kept fresh for so long. Aoud Cuir d’Arabie smells like cheap goatskin and I love it for this. Try to see if you have Sandflowers in your bunch of samples. This really defies anyone’s preconceived notions about Montale

  5. Jordan River says:

    Cooee! Rock that RoseOud Frag Diva.

  6. Dionne says:

    I’m like Ari, I haven’t tried any of the Montales yet, and have barely dipped my toe into the oud section of the pool. However, when I do think of oud, Montale is right at the top of that list so I’ll be trying some eventually (after I work through the figs, and the incenses, and the jasmines and the orange blossoms and…)

    I love the videos you add to many of your reviews, Portia. They’re always interesting.

  7. Ellen Covey says:

    I don’t understand why people are afraid to try Montales. They are much less scary than most mass-market fruity-florals or male aquatics, which really could asphyxiate your neighbor. Maybe the word “oud” or “aoud” scares people, but most of the Montales really don’t seem to contain any significant amount of oud, real or synthetic.

    My favorite Montale, of those I’ve tried, is White Aoud. I generally avoid fragrances with “white” in the name, but in this case, I took a chance and found that it smells much better than it sounds.

  8. sinnerman01 says:

    Wow ! The isolation and control the dancer has is far out!!!!! What an amazing talent ,belly dancing is really cool and not as easy as she makes it look ! I wonder what her SOTD was for that performance ? Opium would be an obvious choice but im thinking maybe a seductive Jasmine bomb !!!! Thanks for sharing , I have not had the long strong pleasure of Montale fragrance ! Sounds wonderful thou ! Hugs xxx

  9. odonata9 says:

    Oh, your description of Montales had me cracking up! I’m no fan of oud, so I’ve only tried one Montale – Vanille Absolu, I think. It was nice, but nothing I need to own. I’ve never heard of this one, so happy to read a review, even though I don’t think it will be up my alley!

  10. Undina says:

    I’m not afraid of Montale perfumes but a couple that I tried were awful on me: I do not like agarwood that much. Plus I really dislike their bottles. So I think I’ll pass on this line for now. If one day I find myself at a store that carries the brand with absolutely nothing else to test, I’ll try at least a couple more but for now I’m fine reading nice reviews like yours 😉

    • I love you Undina. THE BEST!!
      I can understand the agarwood problem, when I wear them Jin says really loud, POOH! COW POOH! and when people comment on them he says it again. He smells only POOH.
      I am laughing while I write this because he is SO DAMN FUNNY! When he doers it I fall over, even though I expect it it gets me every time.
      Portia xx

      • Undina says:

        ❤ ❤ ❤
        I want to mention that cumin smells even worse on my skin. I can take some agarwood or some cumin in my perfumes but a little more – and all I can think of is a shower 😉

  11. Jackieb says:

    You are brave indeed!
    I have not been able to start on Oud…I have a bottle of the essential oil and all I can think of is wet Flokati rug. Eew!

  12. The last I tried was Lime Aoud and it was sharp and overpowering and metallic. Yuck. I have to admit that one thing that keeps me away are their bottles, which don’t look like perfume bottles to me, but rather home cleaner or bathroom spray bottles instead. Keep going though P. If anyone can find a lemming it’s you!

    • OMG!! You are right. they look like 80’s mousse bottles. HA HA HA!
      Excellent call Scented Hound!!
      I will continue the search,
      Portia xx

    • Christos says:

      I must admit Aoud Lime is one to stay away from!!!! Really toxic stuff. Several hours down the road and on somebody else it smells good though.

      These bottles do not take any medals for beauty but they are exactly the kind of container professionals use to store perfumery oils and they are the best way to preserve a perfume unaffected by time.

  13. Margeaux says:

    You need to try and blog that Lime Aoud now Portia – I wanna know what you think too!!

  14. Ellen Covey says:

    Everyone is right, the Montale bottles are hideous. Not that I’ve ever seen one in person, given that all I ever buy are samples or, in rare cases, small decants. Judging by the photos, I think the look they’re going after is the large aluminum bottles that aroma chemicals typically come in. But why?

    • Someone said it was to keep them fresh Ellen. I get that, it makes sense if they are using loads of the good stuff which their pricing indicates.
      They look really big in the pictures, I’ve never seen them in life. I will definitely do so in January/February while in Europe.
      Portia xx

  15. Dubaiscents says:

    I didn’t try the Montales for a really long time not because of the scent but because the bottles are so hideous. I can’t remember which blogger said they look like expensive Axe but, I thought that was a perfect description. Then I found a bunch of them at a discount store and decided to give a couple a shot. My favorite so far is Red Aoud which had a lot of chocolate in the dry down. As you mention, I love how they have so much time with each stage of the scent. You really can differentiate between top, middle and base but, they go so well together. Thanks for the great review, I have to try this one now.

  16. […] Monday I had my first sniff into the big, bad, scary world of Montale (<<Jump to read). Guess what? It wasn’t any of that, um, no, I mean yes, it IS big! […]

  17. Orpheus75 says:

    Montale Black Musk my favorite – a slinky dirty animal! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s